
The Baseball Writers Association of America has handed out it’s awards for the season, which of course means that 1,433 sports radio hosts and 40,293 bloggers all get to scream about how they got this award wrong or that award wrong. Well, not this blogger (so far). The BWAA has announced the winners for seven of their eight awards so far, and I’ve got to say, they’ve nailed it. That’s not to say I won’t have a few interesting comments though. Looking at the awards one by one…
Evan Longoria, AL ROY
No Red Sox fan should be arguing against this. The guy was money all season long, and again in the playoffs, which I know don’t count towards the voting. The only other viable option was Alexi Ramierz, but it’s hard to give an award to a toothpick.
Geovany Soto, NL ROY
I know as a Sox fan my views are a little skewed right now, but what’s not to like about a young, good hitting, solid defensive catcher. Did I mention he’s young? What we wouldn’t do to get him in a Sox uniform right about now.
Joe Maddon, AL Manager of the Year
66-96 to 97-65 with basically the same set of players? And yet the MFY fans are probably still saying that Joe Giradi should get the award.
“Sweet” Lou Pinella, NL Manager of the Year
Pinella did guide his team to the best record in the NL, and with no other clear-cut winner, it’s probably the right call. But to play devil’s advocate here, I’ll bring up two other possibilities. That manager in LA who guided his team to the NL West title could have won it. I think the MFY fans can remember his name. The other option is to just give Maddon the award twice. If you think about it, Pinella managed in Tampa for three seasons and could never get more than 70 wins. So who’s really the better manager here?
Cliff Lee, AL Cy Young
22-3 with a 2.54 ERA? Yeah, those are Cy Young numbers right there. Ironically, his last start of the season was not only a loss, but to the Sox when they got to clinch a wild card berth. So that means that the past two Cy Young award winners have not only been from Cleveland, but have lost their final games of the year to the Sox.
Tim Lincecum, NL Cy Young
Living in the Bay Area, this was certainly the highlight of the season for both teams. I got to watch Lincecum pitch on a number of occations at Pacbell AT&T SBC Park, and his stuff is flat-out nasty. He was in the zone this season where he could tell you what he was going to throw and you couldn’t hit it. OK, maybe not you in particular, but a major league hitter. And in case my finely tuned scouting report isn’t enough to get the award, here are some numbers: 18-5 (normally not a good stat, but the 18 wins were 25% of the victories for the Giants), 2.62 ERA and 265 K’s!
Albert Pujols, NL MVP
Proof that being a well-rounded hitter is better than just hitting long balls. Sure, he had nine fewer homers than Ryan Howard, but he hit over 10% better, got on base 12% more often and struck out 145 fewer times! If you think about that, it’s almost one fewer strike out per game. And even with the home runs, Pujols still had a better slugging percentage.
Of course, the award the Sox fans care about the most comes out tomorrow. The jockey has already won the gold-glove and silver slugger for second basemen, officially making him the best one in the AL. Let’s see if the BWAA can get one more award correct before coming up with ridiculously stupid trade rumors (Julio Lugo for Albert Pujols!) during the offseason.